Should I Buy a New or Used Car?

Compare cheap car insurance

✔ Compare cheap car insurance quotes
✔ Over 110 insurance providers
✔ Get a quote in minutes
✔ Save up to £504*

Deciding between buying a new or used car can be challenging. Let’s weigh the advantages and disadvantages of both options to help you make an informed decision.

What to think about when Buying a New or Old Car

Deciding between buying a new or used car requires careful consideration. While a new car offers the allure of a fresh-from-the-factory vehicle tailored to your preferences, a used car may provide better value retention.

It’s important to factor in running costs such as taxes, insurance, maintenance, and fuel efficiency when making your decision. Let’s explore the advantages and disadvantages of each option to assist you in making an informed choice.

How much can you save on your car insurance?

Get a quote

What are the Pros and Cons of Buying a New Car?

Pros of buying a new car:

Reliability: A new car should have fewer mechanical issues since it hasn’t experienced wear and tear.
Warranty: New cars come with a warranty, providing cover for potential repairs and maintenance costs.
Maintenance: Leasing a new car often includes a maintenance plan, alleviating the need to pay for servicing and certain repairs.
New technology: New cars often feature the latest advancements in safety and convenience, enhancing the overall driving experience.
Customisation: Ordering a new car allows you to tailor the specifications to your preferences, including colour, interior features, and safety enhancements.
Fuel economy: New cars are designed to be more fuel-efficient and environmentally friendly, resulting in lower fuel and road tax costs.
Better finance deals: Dealerships often offer attractive finance packages, such as 0% finance or low-cost lease deals, for new cars.
Perfect condition: New cars are in pristine condition with no previous owners, ensuring an untouched and fresh vehicle.

Cons of buying a new car:

Price: New cars tend to be more expensive than used cars, especially when adding optional extras.
Depreciation: New cars depreciate quickly, losing a significant portion of their value as soon as they are driven off the dealership lot.
Waiting time: Ordering a new car can involve a waiting period, especially if customisation options are chosen.
Higher insurance costs: The value and desirability of a new car can result in higher insurance premiums, reflecting the potential risk of theft or damage.

Overall, the decision to buy a new car should consider factors such as budget, preferences, and long-term financial implications.

How much can you save on your car insurance?

Get a quote

What are the Pros and Cons of Buying a Used Car?

Pros of buying a used car:

Price: Used cars are generally more affordable than brand-new ones, making them a cost-effective option.
Less depreciation: Used cars have already experienced the majority of their depreciation, so they tend to hold their value better than new cars.
Ready to go: Once the necessary paperwork, taxes, and insurance are sorted, you can drive the car away immediately.
Ownership: Buying a used car outright gives you full ownership, allowing you to customise and modify the vehicle as desired.

Cons of buying a used car:

History: It can be challenging to know the complete history of a used car, especially when purchasing from a private seller. There may be undisclosed issues or a previous accident history.
Limited warranty: Most used cars no longer have a manufacturer warranty, and private sellers may not offer any warranty. It’s important to thoroughly inspect the car and ask the right questions before buying.
Limited customisation: Used cars are already equipped with the specifications and features available at the time of manufacturing, leaving little room for customisation.
Condition: Used cars will show signs of wear and tear, with varying degrees of minor or potentially costly issues.
Safety: Safety standards evolve over time, and older used cars may not meet the latest safety ratings set by organisations like Euro NCAP.

When considering a used car, it’s crucial to conduct a thorough inspection, request maintenance records, and get a vehicle history report to make an informed decision.

Did you know

In 2021, there was a significant increase in the adoption of cleaner and greener vehicles among UK motorists. One out of every six new car registrations were plug-in hybrids, and one out of every nine registrations were fully electric cars.

Related: What cars are cheap to insure?

This combined number of electrified car registrations, in various forms, now accounts for 27.5% of the total market. This demonstrates a substantial shift towards more environmentally-friendly transportation options in recent years.

How much can you save on your car insurance?

Get a quote

How has COVID affected Used Car Prices?

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on the prices of second-hand cars in the UK.

The global car manufacturing industry has been heavily affected, causing a shortage of essential components like semiconductor microchips and other raw materials. Consequently, the production of new cars has been delayed, leading to increased demand for used cars and a subsequent rise in prices.

If you are in the market for a used car, it is crucial to adhere to your budget and conduct thorough research. Armed with knowledge, you will be better equipped to negotiate a favourable deal and know when it is wise to walk away.

It is important to approach the buying process with a pragmatic mindset, prioritising practical considerations over emotional impulses.

How much can you save on your car insurance?

Get a quote

Is it Cheaper to Insure a New or Old Car?

Determining whether it is cheaper to insure a new or old car is not straightforward. The cost of your insurance premium depends on various factors, including the age of your car.

Generally, newer cars tend to have better safety and security features, which can potentially lower insurance costs. However, insurance providers may have to bear higher replacement costs for newer vehicles, impacting the premium.

Additionally, new cars can be more attractive to thieves, leading to increased premiums. Keep in mind that car insurance is personalised, taking into account your specific circumstances, the type of car you own, and your location.

To find the most suitable policy at an affordable price, it is advisable to compare car insurance quotes from multiple providers. Comparoo can assist you in comparing different options to find the best deal for your needs and budget.

How much can you save on your car insurance?

Get a quote

Frequently asked questions

Should I consider a nearly new car?

If you’re set on owning a new car but don’t want to consider a second-hand vehicle, a pre-registered or nearly new car can be a great option. Main dealers often acquire new models for use as demonstrators or loan vehicles for their sales staff.

In some cases, pre-registered cars are available at significantly lower prices compared to their original cost. If you can find a car that is only a few months old with minimal mileage, you may be able to secure a fantastic deal.

However, it’s important to note that with pre-registered cars, you may not have the flexibility to choose the colour or specific specifications. Similar to buying a used car, you’ll have to accept the vehicle as it is.

Should I buy new or used for my first car?

Deciding between a new or used car for your first car can be challenging. A new car can provide the latest safety features and advanced assistance systems, giving you a sense of confidence while driving.

Additionally, a new car is statistically less likely to experience breakdowns and leave you stranded. However, purchasing a used car is generally more budget-friendly.

Regardless of whether you choose a new or used car, it is recommended to opt for a small car with a less powerful engine for your first vehicle. Not only will it be more affordable to insure, but it may also offer better fuel economy, helping you save on running costs.

What are my rights when buying a new or used car?

When buying a new or used car, it’s important to be aware of your rights as a consumer. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 provides certain protections for both new and used cars purchased from official car dealers. Here are some key points to consider:

Satisfactory Quality: The car should be of satisfactory quality, taking into account its age and mileage. It should be free from defects and in a condition that a reasonable person would expect.
Fit for Purpose: The car should be fit for the purpose it is intended for. For example, if you purchase a car for daily commuting, it should be able to perform this function without significant issues.
As Described: The car should match the description provided by the dealer, whether it’s in promotional materials, advertisements, or verbal representations.

Related: Smart car insurance

If the car fails to meet these requirements, you have certain remedies available:

Within 30 Days: If you discover a fault with the car within the first 30 days after purchase, you have the right to reject the car and request a full refund.
Within 30 Days to 6 Months: If a fault arises within the first 30 days but before six months, you have the right to ask the dealer to repair the car, replace it, or provide a refund. The dealer must cover the costs of any necessary repairs or replacements.
After 6 Months: After six months, the burden of proof shifts to you to demonstrate that the fault was present at the time of purchase. However, you may still be entitled to certain remedies, such as repairs or partial refunds.

It’s important to note that buying a used car from a private seller offers fewer legal protections compared to purchasing from an official dealer. In such cases, you should thoroughly inspect the car and ask relevant questions about its condition before making a purchase. The Sale of Goods Act 1979 may provide some protection by ensuring that the car matches the description given by the seller.

To ensure a smooth car-buying experience, it’s advisable to keep records of all communications, agreements, and any issues that arise during the process. If you encounter difficulties resolving a dispute with a dealer, you may seek further assistance from consumer protection agencies or legal professionals.

When is the best time to buy a new or used car?

When it comes to buying a new or used car, timing can sometimes play a role in securing a better deal. Here are some insights into the best times to buy:

Best times to buy a new car:

End of each quarter: Towards the end of March, June, September, and December, dealers aim to meet their sales targets. This can present an opportunity to negotiate further discounts, although high public demand may affect the availability of deals.
August and February: These months, just before the release of new number plates, can be advantageous for buyers. Many customers prefer to wait for the latest plates, so dealers may be more flexible on pricing to clear their current stock.
New model launches: Stay updated on upcoming releases and updated versions of models. Dealers may offer discounts on outgoing models to make room for new inventory.

Best times to buy a used car:

September and March: After the release of new number plates, dealers often receive a surplus of older vehicles through part-exchange deals. To clear their used car stock, they may be open to accepting lower offers.
August and February: As dealers prepare for number plate changes, they are typically motivated to sell older stock and make way for new arrivals. This can create opportunities for buyers to negotiate better prices.

While timing can provide some advantages, it’s important to consider other factors such as your personal requirements, budget, and the overall condition of the car. Researching and comparing prices from different sellers is crucial to ensure you get the best possible deal.

Remember, market conditions and individual dealer strategies can vary, so it’s always a good idea to stay informed and be prepared to negotiate. Additionally, keep in mind that finding the right car that meets your needs and offers good value for money should be the primary focus of your purchase.